Hotel Montreal - Florence

7.9

good clean hotel,good enough for 2-3 night stay close to train station and 10-15 min walk from piazza duomo

6.9

As I was directed to stay at an affiliated hotel 'down the road' the pics and location did not match that on the web pages. That said, the staff member who was sporadically present was very pleasant and helpful and the room was clean and air-conditioned. It is located quite centrally to both transport and attractions. There is an internet point next door and reasonable restuarants and bars quite close by.

9.8

Great place for a low price! The rooms were clean, the front desk was very helpful. Overall I rate Hotel Montreal a 10. If you're looking for a place to stay and you're on a budget, this place is for you.

7.4

The Montreal is close to the Rail and Bus stations, so was very convenient for us as rail travellers. We walked to all the city centre sights and took buses to Fiesole and Siena. Accomodation was comfortable though our room (110) was on the small side. Air conditioning was essential - there was little natural ventilation. Breakfast was better than average, though not included in the price. Staff were helpful and friendly. We booked 4 days initially then extended by two days. The price for these two was less than half the first two! I felt the price overall was high for a one star hotel, but the central location meant we were living in historic Florence rather than just visiting it.

10

The staff was one of the friendliest out of all the hotels I stayed at during my trip. So helpful and willing to go above and beyond. The only bummer was that the internet wasn't always reliable. Other than that, I would definitely stay here again. Clean and spacious rooms with a rustic Italian feel.

7.7

Although a good price, this place had the feel of being a "flashpackers" rather than a hotel. While there was some sound proofing, the neighbourhood (and some of the hotel clientale) was very noisy and meant earplugs becoming a necessity... The location was convenient (near the train station etc. but a little dodgy at times.

8.1

One of the best hotels we experienced in Italy. It is much better than the the one star standard it is given. We had a clean spacious room, but we noticed that some other rooms were not as large. We may have been given a larger room for booking for 6 nights. Ensuite was smallish but modern and clean. Convenient location near the railway station and the tourist information centre. Breakfast was good as was the service. The breakfast area is a bit cramped though. The receptionists spoke fluent English and were helpful. We would stay at the Montreal again without hesitation.

9.9

I stayed in the dependency (Hotel Elite) about a block away from the 'mother' Hotel Montreal (which the sites' pics correspond to). It was great! The room was cheerful and clean. The receptionist (Nadya) was so helpful and welcoming. The place was quiet. THe room I had overlooked the street which could be a bit noisy at times but it's a city, you deal. It was air-conditioned, a definite plus. The location was convenient to the train station (without being dodgy) and about a 10 minute walk from the city center. THere was a shower in the room which was great. THe WC was shared but it was clean and never an issue; it was almost like staying in a house with other guests rather than in a hotel. There were only about 10 rooms so not really that stark hotel feel. Very quiet (which of course depends on who is staying there as well). I would absolutely stay there again, especially for the price. I was a woman travelling alone and felt very safe.

8.0

The room, wlthouhg booked at the Montreal, was not in the Montreal but in an adjacent - about 6 building away - "hotel (called depandance - lower end hotel). It was ok but had not elevator.

7.3

We have stayed at the Montreal before so knew what to expect. Having booked a superior room however we were offered room 110 which is so small that there was not space for a wardrobe. We queried this with the front desk and were then offered room 103 which is a triple and spacious. There was no hassle about the change and we only paid for a double.Although the road outside was noisy this room had quadruple glazing so was very quiet. We found the staff friendly and helpful and the breakfast adequate. Anyone with mobility problems should be aware that lift only goes to the first floor. The hotel is situated within easy reach of all major attractions and - if you get the right room - good value for money.

7.8

My 12YO daughter and I stayed here for 2 nights. It was easily accessible from the train station which was important to us. The room was clean and the staff friendly. The area was a bit seedy but we didn't hang around after dark so it wasn't a bother to us. There was street noise, however the 2 sets of double glass certainly took the edge off the volume. We had a shared bathroom which did not cause any inconvenience. The restaurant 2-3 doors down (Lion Grotto or something) had very tasty and affordable meals and a large selection. If you are just looking for somewhere to rest your head at an affordable price the Montreal should suit your needs.

5.9

I had a single room. The hotel has all its single rooms in facing the street, it can be very noise at night because there is a bar next to it. Sometimes it was still noise like 4 in the morning. The door is paper thin. Every word whispered can be heard in the room. I had to change to a double room at the back of the hotel for 3 nights. Do not stay in the hotel.

9.1

Our room was in the front and with windows open it was noisy. Son's room was in back and excellent. This was a wonderful surprise, much nicer than expected and real close to train station.

4.5

They gave us (we are 5 person family) 2 rooms, but it's not in this hotel building. Even 100 meters far away, but there is not anyone in the counter. We felt it's not so safity. I asked the wireless internet, but I don't get the good answer and friendly reply. I didn't feel good for this hotel.

8.1

Nice hotel and staff. Very good location, near Santa Maria Novella and few minutes from historical center.

5.9

In general our stay was ok. The room was clean although a bit on the small side - aside from the bed there is not enough floor space to open 2 suitcases. The internal structure of the hotel is also a bit confusing as the elavator only goes up one floor and then you'll have to go through a maze of corridors to find stairs leading up to the floor higher. The service is ok but the internet access seems to be at too high rate and not sure about the 5 euro deposite for borrowing an adaptor to the power outlet. Having said all that, the room is very quiet being right behind the train station. And the location is excellent.

9.4

Montreal could not give us a smokefree room as asked and referred us to their Elite Hotel from the same group just 100 meters up the road. This rating is for Hotel Elite. Hotel is on the first floor, no lift - our room was at the top (3 flights of stairs) outlooking the back yard and overlooking the rooftops. Walking distance from all the historical buildings and sites. About 300 meters from the train station. No breakfast available at Elite but we could arrange breakfast at Montreal which was excellent,4 Euro per person. Leather markets were a shopper's dream and you can bargain the price!

7.7

Breakfast wasn't included, but they gave it to as anyway because we paid by cash. The elevator only reaches the 1st floor, what is an inconvenient for the luggage.

7.9

good positioning nar the centre and within easy reach of all sights in florence

8.0

We had a nice stay in the hotel. The only thing I would like to mention is Breakfast didnt have much variety otherwise the Hotel is good in terms of price and location.

9.0

This is a great comfortable hotel. Good location, nice attentive staff, and a good value. I highly recommend.

8.2

Excellent location in close proximity to railway station and SITA station. A good point to other places like Siena and San Gimignano.

9.0

Nice and quite hotel. Room was very big. Three beds were given instead of two (what we asked for). Toilet was really clean. The elevator doesn't reach to the third floor, so we had do take the stairs, but it was ok. one minute walk to the main station. walking distance to many florence tourist attractions. Price was so reasonable to the service you get. I recommend this hotel if you are looking for hotel with budget.

3.6

Check that you do not get a room located out the back in another annexe.Our room was small and cramped and claustrophobic and when we asked for a room with a window we were just ignored. If you are considering this hotel DON'T.

7.6

I had a pleasant stay there - I was traveling alone, it was close from the station and quiet enough for me to catch sleep at night. It was a bonus they offer free WiFi access if you have a WiFi-enabled laptop (you have to register for either 1-hr or 12-hr pass at the front desk). My room was very small but enough for me to crash for two nights. Shared bathroom was clean enough, I rarely competed with my neighbors for the bathroom use. If you look for any additional comfort than a decent bed, tv and shared bath, then this is not for you, but if you just need a base for the stroll in town close from the train station, I'd highly recommend - bargain for the price, definitely.

7.4

The room with WC and shower was not available so we were quite happy to take an acceptable room for 48 euros per night with adjacent facilities, which we thought very good considering its good location.

8.4

very nice hotel,high security,pleasent personal, evrything as expected.

6.2

Room was very clean, however, small. Breakfast is 4 euros per person. Rather expensive for a roll and a glass of water. Staff was very nice. Great restaurant next door that stays open until 1 A.M. and has very good food and prices

9.1

We stayed in Florence just one night, and it was our first visit to the Hotel Montreal. The situation was good, the staff were very welcoming, our bedroom was clean and quiet, and the breakfast was excellent. All in all, a very good experience and we would certainly stay at this Hotel again, and recommend it.

9.6

très satisfait des prestations,personnel charmant,

8.0

We only stayed one night and looked for a cheaper hotel that was close to the train station as we had a early train out of Florence. The hotel was not the cleanest we came across, but it wasn't a pigsty either. The 7AM wake up call by the trash collectors outside in the alley was not helpful to the quietness rating. There is a bar next door that attracts people until the early AM hours, but the noise from their patrons in the alley surprisingly did not carry up to our room. I can see it being intimidating for foreigners to have to walk past that on a nightly basis though as the crowd spilled well into the street and adjoining alley. The room was on the small side and the bathroom was small as well, but if you are looking for a cheaper hotel that is relatively close to everything this is not a bad choice. We would probably look to stay somewhere else next time, but would not be bothered if we had to stay here again.

6.9

Stayed at the Montreal with friends - there room was huge, ours was tiny! Clean and adequate though, and convenient location.

7.9

Excellent location, very convenient for the railway and bus stations. Easy walking distance to the main sites.

9.3

La estancia en este hotel fue perfecta, la relación calidad precio esta por encima de lo que se podría pedir. Muy centrico, y de facil localización. He estado en varios hoteles económicos de Florencia y me quedaría con este. Gracias por una perfecta estancia...

4.7

+ve Good Location -ve MOVED TO DIFFERENT CHEAPER DIRTIER NOISIER HOTEL Staff not that friendly charged credit card prior to arrival

7.7

Rooms small but fine for the price. Shared bathroom was big and clean. Simple but nicely decorated for a budget hotel. Nice staff. On request, I could get hot drinking water too. Enjoyed my stay !

9.2

Conveniently located less than 200 meters from main train station and central bus station. Close to Florence highlights. Helpful staff, easy to find, good for a transition/travel day or for exploring Florence.

8.2

We have stayed for just 1 night. The room was really nicely decorated and comfortable. We took a room with a shared bathroom and although the bathroom was very clean in future I would only book rooms with on-suite bathrooms (personal choice). There is a pub next to the hotel and it was a bit noisy at some stage but not too much to keep you awake all night. For the price and location (very close to train station - 5 minutes walking) I would recommend this hotel.

9.1

We really enjoyed our very short stay at the Montreal, after the dreadful ho(s)tel in Rome. The Montreal was a real great place. It is excellently located, we would recommend it and we would stay there again.

5.3

Imagine hearing a dinging noise going off every few minutes for hours straight, overhearing arguments in languages you cannot understand at 2 in the morning, having a light shining in through the windows as the curtains were not darkening the room, and having pillows that resembled rocks in their hardness? That is what this room was like. I booked the room four months before my arrival. I did not expect to be given a room by the elevator, an elevator which beeped every time the door was opened or shut, an elevator which was the only means of going upstairs as there was no stairs. I also did not expect to have a public phone, with no booth or anything to quieten it only 2 meters from the room, and to have a room facing the street. I was given the worst room in the place, a room which should be given to people who book at the last minute, or come in and ask for a room. I also expected a double shared bath to be shared between two rooms, not five. To separate it, and make the double mean the amount of people who can stay in the room, it should have been written with a comma between the two to mean two separate items, not together as the lack of a comma suggests. This is the rule for English, and also for Italian. (I teach English, so I asked a co worker who teaches Italian, and she said it was supposed to be there in Italian also to separate it). It should have read: double, shared bath, not double shared bath. It was the worst experience of all the places we stayed in for four weeks, even worse than staying at the youth hostel in Venice. It was quieter in the youth hostel, believe it or not.

9.1

my room was right next the lift so it was very noisy...

7.9

A lovely accommodation located around the corner from the bus depot and walking distance to major sites. The inner courtyard room was quiet and the air conditioning was great. The staff were extremely helpful and friendly. They directed us to some wonderful restaurants. My sister and I enjoyed the room.

6.0

I felt the rooms I booked thru Venere were unusually small, or on top floors, or on streets where the noise was intense. I looked at other rooms for 2 people and they were quite spacious. Do you get the tail end of rooms available?? I found that by booking once there, thru a TI, our rooms were larger, quieter, and just overall nicer and cheaper.

7.9

This was a great location and a quiet, clean hotel with reasonable rates. The people at the front desk were helpful, fluent in English, and provided us with a fantastic map. The only discrepancy was that the Web site quoted a 3 Euro price for breakfast and we were billed twice that. They also tried to bill us for three days' breakfasts when we only had two, so be sure you go over your bill carefully before you pay. Oh, and there is an Irish pub next door where people hang out in the alley late at night, so be sure to ask for a room not facing the alley or the street.

8.4

It has a relly big romm, not a big bathroom but the service is good, I recomend the hotel breakfast. The locations is good, just one block from train station, and also near from important places.

4.3

I cannot recommend this hotel because of the location right next door to a very nasty looking bar. It was noisy also as our room faced the street. The room was very small, cramped and the bathroom facility was barely suitable. I was happy to leave after three nights there.

9.9

The hotel is extremely well located, literally a couple of blocks away from SMN train station. We had a very spacious and quiet room with private bathroom. The prices are among the lowest I saw while in Florence.

7.4

I chose the Hotel Montreal for its proximity to stazione Santa Maria Novella on account of an early morning flight and was not at all disappointed by the decision. There was a 2:00-6:00 lock out period that I wasn't aware of before hand (I might have missed it on the facilities info?) but a helpful clerk offered to meet me at 5:00 to help me get to the airport shuttle bus. A nice stroll from Piazza Santa Maria Novella and the downtown area. The raucous student pub next door could be a blessing or a bother, but either way the noise didn't seem to drift into the hotel. Overall, a short and sweet stay.

8.7

Room was fine and location excellent. Close to the train station and car rentals and an easy walk to all sites. Breakfast was an extra 4 euros, which was an excellent value. Most of the staff were pleasant and helpful, except for the fellow that checked us in. We did have a problem with a leaky toilet, which was resolved satisfactorily. We had a recommendation from the front desk for a great restaurant close by (La Martinicca).

6.8

close to train station; however was not told we would have to walk up 2 flights of stairs - especially since this was our last night in Italy and we had lots of stuff!!