Hotel Orto de'Medici - Florence

Average rating:  8.7

Guest type: Family with older children

stayed in Feb 2008

the hotel was fine, but it was difficult to find amoung so many tall buildings! we got lost after a short walk around town and had to take a cab back to find the place!

Guest name: Deborah Seydow Bayliss, USA

Average rating:  8.2

Guest type: Mature couple

stayed in Jan 2008

We were very pleased by the comfort of the hotel, the supportive staff, and the excellent breakfast. The location was close to the principal tourist sites.

Guest name: Richard Browne, United Kingdom

Average rating:  9.1

Guest type: Family with older children

stayed in Apr 2007

loved this place with an easy location for Firenze walking

Guest name: Scott Mason, USA

Average rating:  8.8

Guest type: Family with older children

stayed in Feb 2005

We spent time in Florence as a family and the hotel's famil room was splendid. It was quite a walk out of town but we really enjoyed both the hotel, the trip and the walk enabled us to find a magnificent deli were we enjoyed magnificent take awy pizza slices and other goodies.

Guest name: Paul Monaghan, United Kingdom

Average rating:  8.1

Guest type: Single traveller

stayed in Nov 2007

Great hotel in the centre of Florence. Good price and location, easy walking distance to main attractions. Nice restaurants nearby.

Guest name: RH, Italy

Average rating:  8.8

Guest type: Family with young children

stayed in Oct 2007

The restaurant Accadamie was very nice and the corner pastry shop was excellent. A beutifully restored hotel, mixing the modern facilities (bathroom) with the classic details of the hotel's period. Very nice!

Guest name: JB, USA

Average rating:  8.0

Guest type: Mature couple

stayed in Sep 2007

Very pleasant hotel on a quiet street and close to all the major attractions. The breakfast area was excellent.

Guest name: Rick Meaney, Canada

Average rating:  9.9

Guest type: Young couple

stayed in May 2007

We stayed 3 nights May, 2007. Outstanding hotel, in a fantastic area. Staff were great! Ask for a renovated room. Will stay there again.

Guest name: Greg Petkovich, Canada

Average rating:  8.1

Guest type: Single traveller

stayed in May 2007

Room was small but clean and comfortable, All the concierges were extrodinarily helpful. NONSMOKING!!! Nice frescoes on common first floor. NearSan Lorenzo market and the de MEdici chapels -2 short blocks away from the center of town. Felt safe coming and going at night.

Guest name: Marsha Zellner, USA

Average rating:  7.1

Guest type: Young couple

stayed in Apr 2007

This was my second time in Florence and this time did not meet my memory nor my expectations. In regards to this hotel, it is nice inside, but is located near a "kind of rough" part of town. My wife did not like walking down some of the streets at night. On the other hand, you are near and within walking distance of the Academia and other main attractions. We walked to everything we desired to reach. Rooms are clean and the Cappuccinos are the "Best" I had on our whole trip! Please note that if you drive to Florence and are keeping your car, then the garage is going to cost about 16 euros or 21 euros if you have the Hotel's partner come and valet the car in their garage (which is what we did and they took care of the car without an issue). The cost for this was an unexpected surprise to us upon our arrival. Outside of that, it is a nice three star hotel with a good staff.

Guest name: Blake Richter, USA

Average rating:  6.6

Guest type: Mature couple

stayed in Mar 2007

Unfortunately the property is old and had sewer gas leaking into the room 24/7. We had to keep lav door and closet door closed and buy air cleaner. I don't believe the room should have been rented as it was so very unpleasant. The staff was very pleasant though and kind to us during our stay.

Guest name: Sandi Baisi, Canada

Average rating:  8.9

Guest type: Not Specified

stayed in Mar 2007

Not knowing about the hotel, we were pleasantly surprised when we saw our room for the price. The staff was very friendly, and helpful in their recommedation for dinner and where to go in Florence. The hotel is centrally located, so all sites are within walking distance. A wonderful hotel, I recommend highly, and will be sure and stay their again on my next visit to Florence.

Guest name: Joseph Crifasi, USA

Average rating:  1.6

Guest type: Not Specified

stayed in Feb 2007

A charmless hotel. Surly, unhelpful reception staff. Common areas and room did not match photos. A poorly furnished room with scruffy paintwork and an old fashioned, inadequate bathroom with plumbing which did not work properly. Poor value for money. This property has more of a feel of a backpackers' hostel than a hotel. Having travelled extensively in Italy, this is one of the worst hotels I have stayed in.

Guest name: Kenneth McLaren, United Kingdom

Average rating:  9.1

Guest type: Family with older children

stayed in Dec 2006

A lovely little hotel. Charming interior, wish we could have stayed in summer for breakfast on the terrace. A little bit of a walk into centre but certainly not enough to put me off booking again. Will always stay here in future.

Guest name: FRANCES BLACKBURN, United Kingdom

Average rating:  10.0

Guest type: Not Specified

stayed in Oct 2006

A gem in the middle of Florence. Perfect location and a walking distance from all the sights. Highly recommended!

Guest name: Philippe Sautot, USA

Average rating:  8.9

Guest type: Family with young children

stayed in Oct 2006

we had a great stay in Florence in Oct 2006, the hotel was great value, lovely and clean and located approx 10 minute walk from the main places. The character of the hotel added to the Italian experience for me and my 3 children. If I had to think of something negative the only thing I can think of was that there was no coffee making facilities in room and our bathroom was small compared to the other rooms, but not really a problem.

Guest name: NEIL MITCHELL, United Kingdom

Average rating:  8.3

Guest type: 

stayed in Oct 2006

This is a very nice hotel, with some quirks from a American traveler's point of view. First, there was no box of facial tissues in the room. This is something I have never seen in any hotel. Indeed, this was the only hotel that we stayed in during our trip to Italy where there were no facial tissues. To me this was petty. Second, and just a bit quirky, was that there was no shower curtain in the bathtub. Taking a shower and keeping the rest of the bathroom dry was difficult. In fairness, I have seen this in other European hotels, but it seems silly. Thos quirks aside, the hotel has charm, and it is located in a great part of the city, near to the University and the Academia Gallery (David), and a 10-minute walk from the Duomo. Of course, since Florence is so small, nothing is far from anything in the city.

Guest name: Steven Zellner, USA

Average rating:  9.9

Guest type: Young couple

stayed in Mar 2006

We made our reservations based on the great reviews on this site. And we are pleased to report that we had a wonderful stay! The staff was exceptionally helpful and friendly. Breakfast was generous and the other dining recommendations from the staff were fantastic. We wish we had spent more time in Florence and at Orto de'Medici. We will certainly stay here again on our next visit. Thank you!!!

Guest name: Shannon Cardellina, USA

Average rating:  8.9

Guest type: Not Specified

stayed in Oct 2006

Was in Florence for a little under one week on business. Was a great hotel in terms of value and quality, however was not the best for the business traveler (no internet, a little far from the train station). Nonetheless would stay again if in Florence for vacation.

Guest name: Blake Piper, Japan

Average rating:  8.1

Guest type: Gay Couple

stayed in Oct 2006

The location was great. It was an easy walk to the Academy and all the major sights. The hotel staff were helpful and offered good advice. The room was small but tidy and comfortable.

Guest name: WC, USA

Average rating:  9.0

Guest type: Mature couple

stayed in Sep 2006

Nous avons beaucoup apprécié notre séjour à "l'Orto di Medici ". L'hotel est très bien situé, proche des sites touristiques tout en étant à l'écart de la foule, rue très calme.Quelques bons restaurants à proximité proposant une cuisine typiquement Italienne. Le personnel est aimable et très serviable. Les chambres bien décorées sont spacieuses et disposent d'une grande salle de bain. Le petit déjeuner copieux peut être pris sur la terrasse au plus grand calme. C'est une bonne adresse que nous recommandons.

Guest name: Jack MARCHAISON, France

Average rating:  9.0

Guest type: Mature couple

stayed in Sep 2006

Excellent location and helpful staff. Far enough from tourist attractions to be quiet, and close enough for easy walking.

Guest name: William Fein, USA

Average rating:  6.2

Guest type: Single traveller

stayed in Sep 2006

the window of my room watched a poor sight and the pillow of my bed was too much high and unconfortable.

Guest name: AC, Italy

Average rating:  8.5

Guest type: Group

stayed in Sep 2006

The location was very convenient, the room was way above average with respect to size, both the bedroom and bathroom were huge (compared to several other cities), and overlooked a lovely courtyard (which we also availed ourselves of in the evenings for a quiet glass of wine!). The staff were quite polite as well. Breakfast was quite good, nice selection. Would certainly come back to this hotel.

Guest name: LF, Canada

Average rating:  9.6

Guest type: Mature couple

stayed in Sep 2006

Ask for room 41. It has a small terrance with a view. The breakfast was excellent. The location was excellent. Very close to most attractions. Around the corner from a major bus stop.

Guest name: Terry` Chase, USA

Average rating:  8.7

Guest type: Mature couple

stayed in Aug 2006

To whom it may concern of the Managementteam of the Orto de Medici hotel: I might have lost my ball point in my room ( I forgor my roomnumber). The pen was the former pen of my father so I am very sad to have lost it although I took special measures to prevent loosing it. It is a silver coloured Parker ballpoint. Could it be you have found it in my bedroom at the Orto de Medici hotel? Thanks for finding out. Greetings H.Derkx

Guest name: Henricus Derkx, Netherlands

Average rating:  8.5

Guest type: Young couple

stayed in Sep 2006

The rooms are really OK. Try to get a room on the backside of the hotel, because the street could be a bit loud at night. If you travel by car, you should plan the route to the hotel with a city map (the one way streets are tricky). I recommend the car drivers to use the parking service, since the hotel has only one parking place for loading direct in front of the hotel. I recommend this hotel for all who want to explore all the sites of interest, because you could reach nearly everything on foot (The Cathedral in about 5 minutes).

Guest name: DU, Germany

Average rating:  9.0

Guest type: Group

stayed in Aug 2006

I stayed in a quad with three other friends and we found the room large enough for all of us (a rare luxury in Italy). We also found the staff at the front desk very helpful, providing us with printouts of the information we needed. The breakfast room was pleasant and the food excellent.

Guest name: Jung Won Hwang, South Korea

Average rating:  8.9

Guest type: Mature couple

stayed in Jul 2006

Lovely hotel with a fabulous terrace bar where breakfast is served each morning. A tranquil oasis within the city.

Guest name: Vikki Koukoullis, Australia

Average rating:  9.9

Guest type: Young couple

stayed in Aug 2006

We had a fabulous experience staying at this hotel. Our room with a terrace was incredibly worth the price, and the welcoming cocktail was very thoughtful. I would highly recommend this hotel!

Guest name: Lauren Blakley, USA

Average rating:  10.0

Guest type: Not Specified

stayed in Aug 2006

Accueil très sympathique, professionnel et irréprochable. Chambre calme, raffinée et spacieuse. Hôtel idéalement situé à quelques pas du centre historique de Florence. Excellent rapport qualité/prix. Une adresse à recommander à tous.

Guest name: Rodolphe Pasini, France

Average rating:  10.0

Guest type: Young couple

stayed in Aug 2006

We had a fantastic stay in a double room with wetroom style shower in the bathroom. Could not fault this hotel: lovely classic Italian decor, great breakfast, quiet surroundings but still very central and the staff were all friendly and helpful. One evening we were served at the reception desk by the owner himself. Good value for a 3star hotel in Florence, we would strongly recommend it to anyone.

Guest name: Tracy Bates, United Kingdom

Average rating:  10.0

Guest type: Family with older children

stayed in Jul 2006

A great place to stay. Close to everything we wanted to do. Friendly employees.

Guest name: David Harris, USA

Average rating:  7.7

Guest type: Heterosexual Couple

stayed in Jun 2006

Decent place (nothing extraordinary) but way too expensive for what it was offering. Definitely does not deserve the price paid. Plus the waitress was not very friendly when I asked for capuchino for breakfast rather than the regular coffee that they offered (the only place in our 2 week vacation where we saw unfriendly waitress). For the price of the hotel, at least I should have receved an excellent capuchino, rather than the capuchino which tastes horribly. Parking is offered for 21 euro, they come and pick up your car and return it when you need it. It was nice that we could leave our luggage at the hotel after we checked out while we were sightseeing the city.

Guest name: TG, USA

Average rating:  8.7

Guest type: Heterosexual Couple

stayed in May 2006

Excellent location for seeing Firenze in a short period of time. Helpful staff and nice terrrace off of the first floor. We would stay at Orto de'Medici again and will highly recommend it to our friends.

Guest name: SE, USA

Average rating:  9.9

Guest type: Group

stayed in Apr 2006

We all loved this hotel, and would happily stay there again - or recommend it to our friends! The staff were terrific - we were a party of 9 which grew to be one of 11, and consequently had some complicated arrangements to sort out both before and on arrival. Can't praise the professionalism of the reception staff enough! They were helpful and attentive throughout our stay. The hotel facilities would have done credit to a 4 star - we especially loved the terrace, and not just for its historical associations. Being in the university quarter also gave us access to some good restaurants at very reasonable prices.

Guest name: Marian Carey, United Kingdom

Average rating:  7.9

Guest type: Heterosexual Couple

stayed in Apr 2006

This is a lovely hotel, with friendly staff and within easy strolling distance of the main tourist attractions.

Guest name: Brendan Tangney, Ireland

Average rating:  10.0

Guest type: Not Specified

stayed in Mar 2006

We had a quadroom (1 king and 2 double beds) on the top floor and were very pleased with size, cleanliness, and atmosphere of the room. Our room faced toward the Accademia (1 block from the hotel)and we could also see the Duomo. Breakfast was also very nice. Hotel is a few blocks outside of the tourist center, which we enjoyed (quieter and nice neighborhood). While we walked with our roller suitcases to the hotel from the train station, the Florence sidewalks are very narrow which makes this more of a chore than normal - consider a taxi if you have heavy bags.

Guest name: DW, Kazakhstan

Average rating:  10.0

Guest type: Heterosexual Couple

stayed in Feb 2006

nous avons passé trois nuits a l hotel : excellent a tous points de vue!!! nous envisageons de retourner a Florence à l'automne et nous reserverons a nouveau à l'Orto de Medici : chambre agréable,calme et spacieuse, avec balcon et superbe vue sur les toits ,dômes et campaniles,salle de bain très agréable avec grande fenêtre,propreté irréprochable,petit dejeuner à volonté avec un choix remarquable,accueil très agréable et souriant,règlement par carte bancaire accepté avec le sourire également . Idéalement placé dans le centre historique de Florence,à 10 minutes à pied de tous les monuments et musées mais aussi des restaurants . Le service de voiturier à l'arrivée et au départ est hautement appréciable,la voiture étant inutile et surtout pas recommandée vu le plan de circulation confus de Florence et la signalétique très approximative.Le parking privé est peut-être un peu cher,mais tellement plus sur.

Guest name: DANIEL VERY, France

Average rating:  10.0

Guest type: Group of friends

stayed in Jan 2006

very nice and confortable hotel. fantastic for our stay in florence. quality/price excellent.we enjoyed a lot there

Guest name: SIMONA ZAPPA, Italy

Average rating:  9.9

Guest type: Single leisure traveller

stayed in Jan 2006

I stayed here during same week I stayed at Morandi alla Crocetta, and found Orto de Medici to be a much better value (room size, breakfast included in price).

Guest name: Christine Cowell, USA

Average rating:  9.9

Guest type: Group of friends

stayed in Dec 2005

Orto de'Medici is a very agreeable hotel. The hotel staff is attentive and friendly. Friends from the US, Australia and Europe joined me in staying at this hotel. They all were very pleased with the location and accommodations. I was happy that it turned out well for everyone as I chose the hotel from Venere's web site. I will stay here whenever I am in Florence.

Guest name: Joan Schulze, USA

Average rating:  8.8

Guest type: Family Group

stayed in Nov 2005

The rooms were comfortable and the water for showers was plentiful. each member of the family enjoyed different selections during breakfast. Staff was knowledgeable about directions for places we wanted to see.

Guest name: Maureen Nupp, USA

Average rating:  9.8

Guest type: Heterosexual Couple

stayed in Oct 2005

Orto was a great hotel for the money. We had an inner facing room, which was very very quiet (slept great!). Couldn't tell we were next to the elevator. Good storage, Very nicely appointed bathroom (great shower - asked for shower, didn't need/want bath), very nice and helpful staff, very nice breakfast and breakfast room (they will make you eggs if you ask), and Florence is so small you can get anywhere from here in short time. We paid something like $170USD per night, if I recall. There is lobby, but who needs that? I would definitely stay here again and recommend it to anyone seeking a quiet place, and a good value.

Guest name: Steven Goldberg, USA

Average rating:  10.0

Guest type: Heterosexual Couple

stayed in Oct 2005

Very pleasant staff that were very helpful. On a quiet street that is convenient to the major tourist attractions. Excellent breakfast. We would have like a second chair in the room as there are two of us.

Guest name: Ralph Blumenthal, USA

Average rating:  8.8

Guest type: Heterosexual Couple

stayed in Oct 2005

We had a very pleasant stay. The quiet room was ideal for a rest after a long day on our feet in this splendid city. The location of the hotel is very good. We can certainly recommend this hotel as a relaxed place to stay in Florence.

Guest name: Svend Capol, Switzerland

Average rating:  10.0

Guest type: Family Group

stayed in Oct 2005

We were so pleased with our stay here that we decided to return to Florence for our last two days in Italy and were disappointed when the hotel was booked and we couldn't return. Everyone was helpful and the room was clean and spacious.

Guest name: Becky DeVennish, USA

Average rating:  9.6

Guest type: Family Group

stayed in Oct 2005

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at this hotel. PRO:The breakfast room and garden area were very nice, as was the assortment of food at breakfast. The staff were pleasant and helpful. We had two rooms, one of which was larger and had a recently remodeled bathroom. The location is convenient to most everything, especially the San Lorenzo market. CON: My only rant is for the other guests who felt it necessary to have loud cell phone conversations in the hallway outside my room, at 1am.

Guest name: WI, USA

Average rating:  7.3

Guest type: Heterosexual Couple

stayed in Oct 2005

This is a lovely hotel situated in a good position within walking distance of the railway station,internet cafes, laundromat, nice restaurants and the wonderful sights of Florence. Our room was clean, comfortable and attractive, and had doors opening on to a balcony where we could sit and look at the Duomo and the terracotta roofs of Florence.

Guest name: RM, New Zealand

Average rating:  9.0

Guest type: Family Group

stayed in Oct 2005

Very nice, modern rooms, decorated with style. Excellent bathroom with good shower. Very good breakfast with good, if not great, coffee. Friendly and helpful staff. The location is close to many of the major sites and interesting in its own right. The only quibble is that it is a bit expensive, but that is expected in the center of Florence.

Guest name: Charles Ebner, USA